Saturday, February 11, 2012

Orac Unmasked

Orac Unmasked - David H. Gorski, M.D., Ph.D. (Updated)

original source link http://www.patsullivan.com/blog/2005/09/orac_unmasked_a.html

(Posted by Patrick Sullivan Jr.)

GorskioracCompliments of Ashleigh Anderson, the infamous Orac of "Respectful Insolence" has been unmasked.

David H. Gorski
Assistant Professor
UMDNJ-Robert Wood Johnson Medical School
Department of Surgical Oncology
The Cancer Institute of New Jersey

From Ashleigh Anderson's post on the EOH Yahoo board. (You have to be an approved member of the group to view posts, so I've posted the whole thing here):

You know, I was reading the oracknows site the other night & you know how all the pro-poisoning people are - they have this little skeptics circle or whatnot. Well anyways, I did a mouse over of his Blogarama button and noticed the name gorski came up.
So I googled - gorski orac
Try it. You will be amazed. Orac's secret identity is secret no more. And man, has he been a nasty boy. What a slimey sleaze.
No wonder he kept his identity secret. See what he has been doing on the web & his affilication with the Renses/Ratbags.
Now he loses all his credibility.

To Professor Gorski's credit, he did say that if you look hard enough, you can figure out who he is. (And one clue that I noticed was when a friend of his commented on his blog, "Dave, where do you get the time for this? It's cool.")

So basically, this "unmasking" is pretty much a non-event. HOWEVER, after arguing ad nauseum with "Gorac," it is good to finally have some disclosure. It would have been much more credible if it had come from him directly, especially after the repeated calls for disclosure from numerous commentors.

Professor Gorski, I do have one question: In your blog profile, you say, "I'm an academic surgeon and scientist..." and in the description of your blog, you say "Miscellaneous ramblings of a surgeon/scientist..." and in your medical disclaimer, you say "...the author's hospital, university, surgical practice, or partners."

So why don't you have any initials after your name? It seems to me that you have allowed everyone, including me, to believe that you are a real doctor.

UPDATE 9/14 8:27pm from Pat and Patrick Jr. - After discussing this post and the comment by Kev regarding Professor Gorski's contact info being posted, we decided that we didn't want to give the impression of this being a character assasination. So we pulled out the contact information from the post. (As Patrick Jr. notes in his reply to back to Kev, the contact info is still available from his profile page, so it is sort of a moot point, but...)

It is not our intention to "unmask" Orac so that anyone can cyber-stalk/spam/etc. him!! We are proponents of civil debate and discussion. We don't want to promote the type of character assasination that is unfortunately, quite common on Orac's blog.

We have both spent way too much time trying to defend what we believe are highly plausible reasons for numerous things that we believe on Orac's blog, only to then be ridiculed and attacked personally, all the while ignoring and dodging our arguments. (There are many others who have experienced this as well.)

Orac believes what he believes and has every right to express that. We happen to think he is very biased, closed-minded, and often just plain wrong. He also loves to call people terrible names assasinating their character instead of simply stating why he disagrees. And I don't think I've ever see him concede any point, ever! (It is not unlike the near total breakdown in civil discourse at the national political level.)

The "unmasking" is still appropriate because at least now we know who and what we are dealing with.

UPDATE 9/14 8:57pm from Patrick Jr. - I just read Ashleigh's comment on this post which lead to this page. Searching for "orac" I found this:

From: dgorski@xsi-te.net (ORAC)
Date: 10 Dec 1997 15:05:57 GMT

(snip)

ORAC |"A statement of fact cannot be
a.k.a. | insolent." ORAC
David H. Gorski, M.D., Ph.D. |
University of Chicago |

The MD and PhD shocked me considering that I was under the impression he wasn't a doc. So I googled "University of Chicago" "David H. Gorski" which led to this 1998 Univ of Michigan newsletter. Bottom of page 20 has:

David H. Gorski (BSC 1984, MD 1988;
PhD 1994, Case Western Reserve (Cellular
Physiology)) is a Fellow in Surgical
Oncology at the University of Chicago.

I would say that I stand corrected from my earlier question to Gorac...He's a doc after all. No way a Michigan newsletter from 1998 was faked.

UPDATE 9/14 9:07pm from Patrick Jr. - I changed the title of this post from "Orac Unmasked - Assistant Professor David H. Gorski" to "Orac Unmasked - David H. Gorski, M.D., Ph.D. (Updated)" It seemed like the right thing to do.

UPDATE 9/14 10:02pm from Patrick Jr. - I emailed Orac earlier today, so after my new discovery, I thought it was only fair to own up to my mistake and email him again:

---Original Message---
From: Patrick Sullivan
Sent: Wednesday, September 14, 2005 9:25 PM
To:
'oracknows@gmail.com'; 'gorskidh@umdnj.edu'
Subject: RE: This is you right? CORRECTION

Dave, I did a few more googles on my own tonight and found out that lacking initials on your UMDNJ page, you actually do appear to be a real MD and PhD. There's no way I'm going to believe that a Michigan newsletter from 1998 was faked, as much I did sort of like the idea of you not being a real doctor. (Trading places, I'm sure you'd have felt the same way... ;-)

So since I was wrong, I quickly updated/corrected Pat's blog. Not sure if you'll actually care, but I thought it was only fair to ping you.

Here's to disclosure and civil discourse.

Patrick Jr.

---Original Message---
From: Patrick Sullivan
Sent: Wednesday, September 14, 2005 12:01 PM
To:
'oracknows@gmail.com'; 'gorskidh@umdnj.edu'
Subject: This is you right?

Professor Gorski/Orac, it's nice to finally meet you.
http://www.patsullivan.com/blog/2005/09/orac_unmasked_a.html

Patrick Sullivan Jr.
President
480.212.9000 |
patrick@jigsawhealth.com

Jigsaw Health
14500 N. Northsight Blvd. Ste 112
Scottsdale, AZ 85260

www.JigsawHealth.com
The leading resource for chronic conditions.

Pat Sullivan Blog: www.PatSullivan.com

UPDATE 9/14 10:59pm from Patrick Jr. - Orac replies...

---Original Message---
From: Orac [mailto:oracknows@gmail.com]
Sent: Wednesday, September 14, 2005 10:08 PM
To: Patrick Sullivan
Subject: Re: This is you right? CORRECTION

Quite frankly, I have no idea what you wrote the first time around, as I didn't bother to check it out. I was too busy tonight. (I foolishly agreed to host the History Carnival today when I should have been able to foresee that work would be busy this week. Stupid.)

You should now realize that everything I have said about myself and about my reasons for using a pseudonym is true.

Dave

--- My reply back to Orac ---

---Original Message---
From: Patrick Sullivan
Sent: Wednesday, September 14, 2005 10:52 PM
To:
'oracknows@gmail.com'
Subject: RE: This is you right? CORRECTION

Dave, I find it difficult to believe that you weren't in the least bit curious to read about your unmasking, but I'll just take you at your word. (Maybe you've been unmasked a dozen times before and it's become old hat?)

I honestly never thought that you were outright lying about being a doc, though my suspicions to the contrary increased every time you refused a request to disclose your identity. Motives are important things to consider, that's why I'm such a big believer in full disclosure.

I have read most (all?) of your reasons for why you desire to remain anonymous...I sort of get it, but I really don't. Why hide when disclosure would have been on your side? After all, you really are a doc!

This is very much a rhetorical point as I know you have no intention of changing -- which is fine! I don't really care. In order to move on, we can hopefully agree to disagree. And regardless, your previously unknown credentials have never been the basis of any of my arguements with you.

If not to disclosure, here's to civil discourse. Good luck with the history carnival.

Patrick Jr.

15 comments:

  1. This guy is obviously been pussy whipped by the pharmaceutical industry into taking monies for endorsing their products!
    Who would endorse injecting mercury into your body(that's a preservative) that's the second most deadly chemical in the drug arsenal behind radioactive plutonium!
    Well in this idiots opinion that's OK! You're good to go because HE says so. What a fucking moron!
    What could happen? Ohhh, I don't know,maybe a compromised immune system?
    Why do you think doctors of today are treating autoimmune cases in epic proportions?
    Think about this concept guys are we intelligent individuals or are we lemmings that will follow this idiot over the cliff not questing anything he says?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey David, what's up? Are you still a Fucking whining PUSSY or are you a functional mouthpiece of the pharmaceutical industry?
    I would like to get your fucking LIMP version of your excuse for taking the side of your benefactors! The pharma industry that holds your COCK in their hands.
    Give me a jingle I'd love to hear from your uneducated viewpoint on the subject!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Buy Herbal Care Products online. We provide Natural Herbal Remedies, health and skin diseases information. Natural herbal products use men and women without side effects.

    ReplyDelete
  4. There are lots of Natural Remedies for Achalasia in market but these are very expensive. A product made by Natural Herbs Clinic is one of the useful and low prices Natural Remedy for Achalasia which works without any risk. It is a low price product and made with herbal ingredients that work without any side effects.

    ReplyDelete
  5. In adults, treatment for hydrocele typically goes away within six months, according to the Herbal Care Products. Treatment of hydrocele usually needs surgery if it’s a communicating hydrocele because it can lead to hernias or it causes discomfort. We prefer the Herbal Care Products Company, who is creating home remedies for patients. Herbal Treatment for Hydrocele is the “Cedical” product. Best Hydrocele Herbal Treatment help to improve swelling of the scrotum with fluid.

    ReplyDelete
  6. The reasons comprise infective contagion, viral infection and, less typically, chemical irritation. Treatment normally includes antibiotics, painkillers and anti-inflammatory treatment. Full retrieval can take place in just a few days. Early Analysis of Epididymitis means early Epididymitis cure. Make sure you get a remedial diagnosis and Natural Remedies for Epididymitis.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hello, I want to have one of these piercing models, but I am unsure. Can you look at it?

    Men Nose Piercing

    Finger Piercing

    Shark Bite Piercing

    Tragus Piercing

    Daith Piercing For Anxiety


    ReplyDelete
  8. Diet Plan for Weight Loss. A healthy eating plan gives your body the nutrients it needs every day while staying within daily calorie goal for weight loss.

    ReplyDelete
  9. We sell original Herbal Products composed of Natural Herbs Clinic obtained from the world’s top botanic gardens under the cautious administration of experts who are working day and night to make the herbal products even better and to increase the range so that people suffering from certain ailments which do not have any identified care as yet can benefit from our formulas.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Herbal Treatment for Polycythemia Vera read the Symptoms and Causes. Polycythemia Vera is a condition described by an increased number of red blood cells in the bloodstream.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Herbal Treatment for Bronchiectasis can prevent damage to your lungs and improve your symptoms. Herbal Supplement improves the health of the lungs that they function better.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Bearberry is one of the very useful herbal elements for Herbal Treatment for Polycystic Kidney Disease patients and it has superior effects on healing urinary tract infections as well as preventing cyst infection and kidney infection.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Northwell Health therefore, right here is a few records as to the reasons why you should include the Pomegranate fruit on your weight loss program: Eye fitness: This fruit is wealthy in nutrients A, B and C and E. nutrition A is known as the vitamin that supports vision fitness. this is actual from the factor of view of the reality that a deficiency on this vitamin can motive night blindness. https://motian.org/

    ReplyDelete
  14. Granuloma Annulare Natural Treatment will get better the condition of your skin where the lesion is. Herbal Care Products prescribe NULICAL Herbal Treatment for Granuloma Annulare without any side effect. It is most powerful and genetic medicine for herbal treatment of Granuloma Annulare. Itching and mild pain caused by the problem and its Natural Treatment for Granuloma Annulare with herbal supplements. A person can use different Natural Treatment of Granuloma Annulare to obtain relief from this problem.

    ReplyDelete